Get the ‘cure’ out..!

I came across Partha Bagchi’s Stammering Cure Centre in the year 1998, when he advertised on a newspaper in Goa. The advertisement showed a lot of promise, and claimed to be the only centre which can cure stammering in two weeks. My parents planned a visit to the centre. When I visited him for the first time, I was really impressed about the way he talked. He was speaking really slow and didn’t show any trace of stammering. When he told us he was a severe stammerer for 26 years, I was even more impressed. I thought if he can speak like that with his techniques, then his techniques have to be effective! He insisted I should join the 15-day crash course, but then I had to opt for a correspondence course because of my college schedules. I practiced his exercises. A few times I was fluent. But then suddenly one single block was enough for the stammering to return. At this moment, I thought a regular course would be a solution to my problems. Then he held a camp in Goa, where he held his regular course for locals. I attended that course. It was a good experience, with some useful techniques like- Speaking in front of the mirror, speaking in front of the crowd on a microphone, meditation etc. I was 100% fluent during the entire 15 days in those ‘clinical’ conditions. Even a few days after that, I managed to speak slow and maintain fluency. I continued practice. One fine day, I had a bad speaking experience which triggered a relapse. I practiced his techniques for 6 months religiously. Then the roller-coaster ride started of fluent days and not-so-fluent days. I began to blame myself for not being able to do the practice dedicatedly, and thought that I lacked the will power to achieve fluency. In the meanwhile, Partha Bagchi continued to be a role-model, and I always looked up to him as he always gave me a hope that if he can overcome his stammer, so can I. I joined TISA in 2009, and despite knowing the fact that Partha Bagchi was not in the good books of TISA school of thoughts, he remained to be a role model, because of the way he has managed to gain control over his stammering. My opinion about my role model changed because of a few reasons. I read quiet a lot about many other such ‘Cure-centres’ in India as well as other countries. I also read that there was no known cure for stammering. This is the biggest point of objection, which even holds true with Mr. Bagchi’s SCC- the use of the word ‘cure’. What these centres offer are techniques which help us deal with our stammering, techniques which facilitates control over our speech impediment and ways of managing to communicate WITH our stammer. And this is not CURE and should not be sold as CURE. Because the word cure is so tempting to PWS (I am included) that we are ready to shelve any amount of money to find it! Another thing that was shocking about Mr. Bagchi was the fact that he refused to reply to his students who asked his help when they were unable to put his techniques to practice. I had held a great respect for Mr. Bagchi and I believed that he has a motive in his life of helping the PWS. But if he refuses to reply to his students seeking help after failing the course, then it’s not really a help. Because like me, all these PWS will continue to idolize him and victimize themselves for not having tried enough thus trapping themselves into the bog of guilt. I still maintain Mr. Bagchi’s techniques are good and quite helpful, but they don’t cure stammering. I have no problem if Mr. Bagchi charges fees for his crash course. But how does he justify the cost of Rs. 10,000? He will be a role model again if he is open to discussion with self help organisations like TISA, professional speech therapists or any other certifying authority. He will be a role model again if he admits that the use of the word cure is not appropriate and changes the name of his centre to – “Stammering Management Centre”.

4 Comments

Comments are closed.

  1. Sachin 7 years ago

    Thanks Harish. This is the whole purpose: Let there be a DISCUSSION- without bothering who wins. Finally it is the truth and the PWS who should win..
    Your testimony was balanced and objective… I wish more people will write and share..

  2. admin 7 years ago

    These so called "stammering cure centres "are making PWS's life more distressing as the pws losses all their hope after they fail to get that "cure".
    We should make sincere effort to beware the peoples about these 'frauds'.
    Tisa is doing commendable job in this regard..

  3. Anonymous 7 years ago

    What I find is there are mixed responses about SCC. I have also attended the course and got 50 % improvement but maintaining slow speed is sometime difficult for me.

    however, when I was to join the center, I contacted two fellows on orkut who joined the program 4-5 years back. One of said me"What is stammering?" He means that he cured upto that level that he forgets what stammering is. I have also found few people at the center who frequently visited that place because they live in bangalore itsef and they found more help from this course and had faced interviews, GD and got jobs.

    But the fact is that there are 20-30% people who got help otherwise rest others did not find any help and their claim to reduce stammering in 15 days itself is wrong. He said that we have to follow for 8 months.

    So, finally, I believe that the course helps some pws and to say they cure spontaneously is not correct. How that spontaneity comes suddenly after the very moment they joined the course. It is known that not a single treatment works universally for all PWS. This treatment given by Mr.Partho Bagchi works for minor fraction of pws.

  4. To know Stammering Treatment Efficacy Summary click on:

    http://www.asha.org/uploadedFiles/public/TESStuttering.pdf

CONTACT US

We're not around right now. But you can send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap.

Sending

Log in with your credentials

or    

Forgot your details?

Create Account